CASE
1
CASE
2
CASE
3
CASE
4
CASE
5
CASE
6
CASE 7
CASE 8
CASE
9
CASE
10
CASE
11
Discussion
Comment |
Case
7
Herbert B. was referred on
February 5, 1941. at 3 yeras, 2 months of age.
He was thought to be seriously
retarded in intellectual development. There were no physical abnormalities
except for undescended testicles. His electroencephalogram was normal.
Herbert was born November
16, 1937, two weeks before term by elective cesarean section; his birth
weight was 6 ¼ pounds. He vomited all food from birth througt the
third month. Then vomiting ceased almost abruptly and, except for occasional
regurgitation, feeding proceeded satisfactorily.
According to his mother,
he was always slow and quiet.for a time he was believed to be deaf because
he did not register any change of expression when spoken to or when in
the presence of other people; also, he made no attempt to speak or to form
words.He held up his head at 4 months and sat at 8 months, but did not
try to walk until 2 years old, when suddenly he began to walkwithout any
preliminary crawling or assistance by chairs.He persistently refused to
take fluid in any but an all-glass container. Once, while at a hospital,
he went three days without fluid because it was offered in tin cups. He
was tremendously frightened by running water, gas burners, and many other
things,He became upset by any change of an accustomed pattern: if he
notices change, he is very fussy and cries.But he himself liked to pull
blinds up and down, to tear cardboard boxes into small pieces and play
with them for hours, and to close open the wings of doors.
Herberts parents separated
shortly after his birth. The father, a psychiatrist, is described as a
man of unusual intelligence, sensitive, restless, introspective, taking
himself very seriously, not interested in people, mostly living within
himself, at times alcoholic.The mother, a physician, speaks of herself
as energetic and outgoing, fond of people and children but having little
insight into their problems, finding it a great deal easier to accept people
rather than try to understand them.Herbert in the youngest of three children.
The second is a normal, healthy boy. The oldest, Dorothy, born in June,
1934, after thirty-six hours of hard labor, seemed alert and responsive
as an infant and said many words at 18 months, but toward the end of the
second year she did not show much progression in her play relationships
or in contacts with other people.She wanted to be left alone, danced about
in circles, made queer noises with her mouth, and ignored persons completely
except for her mother, to whom she clung in panic and general agitation.(Her
father hated her ostensibly.) Her speech was very meager and expression
of ideas completely lacking. She had difficulties with her pronouns and
would repeat youand I instead of using them for the proper persons.She
was firs declared to be feebleminded, then schizophrenic, but after the
parents separated (the children remaining with their mother), she bolssomed
out.She now attends scholl, where she makes good progress; she talks well,
has an IQ of 108, and-tough sensitive and moderately apprehensive-is interested
in people and gets along reasonably well with them.
Herbert, when examined on
his first visit, showed a remarkably intelligent physiognomy and good motor
coordination. Within certain limits, he displayed astounding purposefulness
in the pursuit of sef-selected goals.
Among a group of blocks,
he instantly recognized those were glued to a board and those that were
detachable. He could build a tower of blocks as skillfully and as high
as any child of his age or even older. He could not be diverted form his
self-chosen occupations. He was annoyed by any interference, shoving intruders
away (without ever looking at them), or screaming when the shoving had
no effect.
He was again seen at 4 years,
7 months, and again at 5 years, 2 months of age.He still did not speak.
both times he entered the office without paying the slightest attention
to the people present. He went after the Seguin form board and instantly
busied himself putting the figures into their proper spaces and taking
them out again adroitly and quickly. when interfered with he whined impatiently.
When one figure was stealthily removed, he immediately noticed its absence,
became disturbed, but promptly forgot all about it when it was put back.
At times, after he had finally quieted down following the upset caused
by the removal of the form board, he jumped up and down on the couch with
an ecstatic expression on his face. He did not respond to being called
or to any other words addressed to him. he sometimes uttered inarticulate
sounds in a monotonous singsong manner. At on time he gently stroked his
mothers leg and touched it with his lips. He very frequently brought blocks
and other objects to his lips. There was an almost photographic of his
behavior during the visits, with the main exception that at 4 years he
showed apprehensino and shrank back when a match was lighted, while at
5 years he reacted by jumping up and down ecstatically.
Case 8
Alfred L. was brought by
his mother in November, 1935, at 3½ years of age with this complaint:
He has gradually shown a
marked tendency toward developing one special interest which will completely
dominate his days activities. He talks of little else while the interest
exists, he frets when he is not able to indulge in it (by seeing it, coming
in contact with it, drawing pictures of it), and it is difficult to get
his attention because of his preoccupation.... there has also been the
problem of an overattachment to the world of objects and failure to develop
the usual amount of social awareness.
Alfred was born in May,
1932, there weeks before term. For the first two months, The feeding formula
caused considereble concern but then he gained rapidly and became an unusually
large and vigorous baby.He sat up at 5 months and walked at 14.
Language developed slowly;
he seemed to have no interst in it. He seldom tells experience. He still
confuses pronouns. Henever asks questions in the form of questions (with
the appropriate inflection), Since he talked, there has been a tendency
to repeat over and over word or statement.He almost never says a sentence
without repeating it. Yesterday, when looking at a picture, he said many
times, Some cows standing in the water.we counted fify repetitions, then
he stopped after several more and then began over and over.
He dad a good deal Of worrying:
He frets when the bread is
put in the oven to be made into toast, and is afraid it will get burned
and be hurt. He is upset when the su sets. He is upset because the moon
does not always appear in the sky at night. He prefers to play alone; he
will get down from a piece of apparatus as soon as another child approaches.
He likes to work out some project with large boxes (make a trolley, for
instance) and does not want anyone to get on it or interfere.
When infantile thumb sucking
was prevented by mechanical devices, he gave it up and instead put various
objects into his mouth. On several occasions pebbles were found in his
stools. Shortly before his second birthday, he swallowed cotton from an
Easter rabbit, aspirating some of the cotton, so that tracheotomy became
necessary. a few months later, he swallowed some kerosene with no ill
effects.
Alfred was an only child.
His father, 30 years old at time of his birth, does not get along well
with people, is suspicious, easily hurt, easily roused to anger, has to
be dragged out to visit friends, spends his spare time reading, gardening,
and fishing.He is chemist and a law school graduate. The mother, of the
same age, is a clinical psychologist,very obsessive and excitable. The
paternal granparents died early; the father was adopted by a minister.
the maternal grandfather, a psychologist, was severely obsessive, had numerous
tics, was given to repeated hand washing, protracted thinking along one
line, fear of being alone, cardiac feras,The grandmother, an excitable,
explosive person, has done public speaking, published several books, is
an incessant solitarie player, greatly worried over money matters,A maternal
uncle frequently ran away from home and school, joined the marines, and
later made a splendid adjustment in commercial life.
The mother left her husband
two months after Alfreds birth. The child has lived with his mother and
maternal grandparents. In the home is a nursery school and kindregarten
(run by the mother), which creates some confusino for the child.Alfred
did not see his father until he was 3 years, 4 months old, when the mother
decided that he should know his fatherand took steps to have the father
come to the home to see the child,
Alfred, upon entering the
office, paid no attention to the examiner. He immediately spotted a train
in the toy cabinet, took it out, and connected and disconnected the cars
in a slow, monotonous manner. He kept saying many times, More train-more
train-more train.He repeatedly countedthe car windows: One, two windows-one,
two windows-one, two windows-four window, eight window, eigth windows,He
could not in any way be distracted from the trains. A Binet test was attempted
in a room in which there were no trains. It was possible with much difficulty
to pierce form time to time through his preoccupations. He finally complied
in most instances in a manner that clearly indicated that he wanted to
get through with the particular intrusion; this was repeated with each
individual item of the task. In the end he achieved an IQ of 140.
The mother did not bring
him back after this visit because of his continued distress when confronted
with a member of the medical profession.In august, 1938, she sent upon
request a written report of his development. From this reprt, the following
passages are quoted:
He is called a lone wolf.
He prefers to play alone and avoids groups of children at play. He does
not pay much attention to adults except when demanding stories. He avoids
competition. He reads simple stories to himself. He is very fearful of
being hurt, talks a great deal about the use of the electric chair. He
is thrown into a panic when anyone accidentally covers his face.
Alfred was again referred
in June, 1941. His parents had decided to live together. Prior to that
the boy had been in eleven different schools. He had been kept in bed often
vecause of colds, bronchitis, chickenpox, streptococcus intection, impetigo,
and a vaguely described condition which the mother-the assurances of various
pediatricians tothe contrary notwithstanding-insisted was rheumatic fever.While
in the hospital, he is said to have behaved like a manic patient.The
mother liked to call herself a psychiatrist and to make psychiatricdiagnoses
of the child. From the mothers report, which combined obsessive enumeration
of detailed instsnces with explanationstrying to prove Alfreds normalcy,the
following information was gathered.
He had begun to play with
children younger than himself, using them as puppets-thats all.He had
been stuffed with music, dramatics, and recitals, and had an excellent
rote memory. He still was terrbly engrossedin his play, didnt want people
around, just couldnt relax:
He had many fears, almost
always connected with mechanical noise (meat grinders, vaccun cleaners,
streetcars, trains, etc.). Usually he winds up with an obsessed interest
in the things he was afraid of. Now he is afraid of the shrillness of the
dogs barking.
Alfred was extremely tense
during the entire interview, and very serious-minded, to such an extent
that had it not been for hs juvenile voice, he might have given the impression
of a worried and preoccupied little old man. At the same time, he was very
retless and showed considerable pressure of talk, which had nothing personal
in it but consisted of obsessive questions about windows, shades, dark
rooms, especially the X-ray room. He never smiled. No change of topic could
get him away from the topic of light and darkness. but in between he answered
the examiners questions, which often had to be repeated several times,
and to which he sometimes responded as the result of a bargain-You answer
my question, and Ill answer Yors.He was painstakingly specific in his
definitions. A ballon is made out of lined rubber and has air in it and
some have gas and sometimes they go up in the air and sometimes they can
hold up and when they got a hole in it theyll bust up; if people squeeze
theyll bust. isnt right?A tiger is a thing, animal, striped, like a
cat, can scratch, eats people up, wild, lives in the jungle sometimes and
in the forests, mostly in the jungle. Isnt right?This question Isnt
it right?was definitely meant to be answered; there was a serious desire
to be assured that the definition was sufficiently complete.
He was often confused about
the meaning of words. When shown a picture and asked, what is this picture
about?he replied, People are moving about.
He once stopped and asked,
very much perplexed, why there was The Johns Hopkins Hospitalprinted
on the history sheets: Why do they have to say it?This, to him, was a
real problem of major importance, calling for a great deal of thought and
discussion. Since the histories were taken at the hospital, why should
it be necessary to have the name on every sheet, though the person writing
on it knew where was writing? The examiner, whom he remembered very well
from his visit six years previously, was to him nothing more nor less than
a person who expected to answer his obsessive questions about darkness
and light.
Cases
9 and 10. |